This one is interesting because I seem to remember so much said about him being great in practice. It was maybe Hunter or North that he consistently played so well against. Then the games and got exposed. I am not saying Butch is great at practice but maybe there is something about him that just self-destructs him and everything around him on game day. I mean Peterman at FL, play calling, who plays, timeouts, etc. maybe he instills a sense of panic or imminent failure in the players.
Coleman played will and hit well, but he got stuck in man on some slot guys running seams right by him and didn't play a few of those well, which sticks in peoples minds imo.