Suck It, Droski.

That was a horrible trade for the Colts. Richardson cannot play.

And where I'm going is that the Colts cannot make a good personnel decision unless it is rather obvious, like should we draft the qb with a pedigree who works hard or the hot-headed guy who's only favored by a media dying for a story.

 

I believe I've made my position rather clear.

Who is more likely to be biased? the guy with no skin in the game or the fanbase that sent death threats to people that dare suggests Peyton didn't deserve the Heisman?

 

his current receiving corps are among the best in the league.

 

Your position is clear. Your supporting arguments are schizophrenic.

 

Jermaine Kearse can outrun people on the long ball

 

Eric Decker wouldn't be any more special than Golden Tate if they were both on the Seahawks.

 

how so? it's you guys that want to turn this into a black and white argument. I've said all along that regular season and post season both matter. you guys want to argue post season doesn't matter, not me. nor have I ever suggested the regular season doesn't matter either.

 

It makes sense that a fanbase that spits on troops returning from Vietnam would blame a qb for defensive failures. Just stupid to see who they should be blaming.

 

decker had 40 receptions with tim tebow at qb. EOT

 

you know me. i'm a commie.

and manning has lost plenty of games where his D showed up. and please show me the last team with an elite d with the highest paid player in football at qb.

 

That's an average of 2 and 1/2 catches a game.

 

golden tate averaged 4 with a qb with a pulse. you don't seriously think tate is better do you?

 

No one ever said postseason didn't matter. Taking a garbage team to the playoffs and losing to the Super Bowl champs doesn't exactly make him the choke artist he's so often painted to be.

 

I'll show you the salary numbers after you show me the "plenty" of games.

My analogy was awful. This isn't misplaced anger or criticism, like the Cal campus treats soilders, you're just not knowledgeable about what you're talking about. You're like U. of Phoenix grad in this thread.

 

Then why in the world am I being shit on for saying he clearly isn't the GOAT if the postseason matters? If he loses the SB he'll have the most losses of any qb in postseason history. He already has the most home losses in post season history. he was favored in many of these games. please explain how they weren't garbage during the regular season and all of a sudden become garbage after that?

 

Hilton, Allen, Fleener, and Ballard all look like good decisions early on.

 

http://espn.go.com/nfl/playoffs/2013/story/_/id/10266254/are-peyton-manning-one-dones-fault

5 games right there where the opposing O scored 23 or less points. and those only his one and done games.

 

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/M/MannPe00/gamelog/post/

1999 17 2000-01-16 23-298 IND TEN L 16-19

2000 17 2000-12-30 24-281 IND @ MIA L 17-23

2003 19 2004-01-18 27-300 IND @ NWE L 14-24

2004 18 2005-01-16 28-298 IND @ NWE L 3-20

2005 17 2006-01-15 29-297 IND PIT L 18-21

2009-01-03 32-285 IND @ SDG L 17-23

2010 17 2011-01-08 34-290 IND NYJ L 16-17

 

ROFL.

 

I don't think either one are anything special.