This should settle it, as I'm sure 'fansided' is a definitive, authoritative source: http://fansided.com/2014/12/11/nfl-power-rankings-30-best-qbs-time/20/ Notables: 1. Montana t2. Brady/P. Manning 4. Marino 10. Rogers 12. Brees 27. E. Manning 28. Roethlisberger
I feel like this post season settles the Manning/Brady controversy for everyone that has a shred of objectivity in their minds.
Since when does making it to the conference championship game matter? Brady's major accomplishments ended with W's first term.
Last year should weigh heavier "for anyone that has a shred of objectivity". unless you want to completely ignore the last time they actually faced off in the playoffs.
And rings. And playoff wins. and head to head... I like Manning. I like that he was and is a Vol. Doesn't change the facts.
Rodgers, Brees, Ben, and Manning have all played at an elite level and won Super Bowls since Katrina. Brady has dropped two to Eli ****ing Manning and couldn't even muster 20 points in the SB when he had the most potent offense in League history.